Skip to content
Home » What Is The Rarest Dum Dum Flavor

What Is The Rarest Dum Dum Flavor

What Is The Rarest Dum Dum Flavor

Dum Dums, the iconic lollipop brand, has been delighting children and adults alike for decades. With a wide range of flavors to choose from, it’s no wonder that Dum Dums are a favorite treat for many. But among the plethora of flavors, which one stands out as the rarest? In this article, we will explore the world of Dum Dums and uncover the elusive flavor that has captured the curiosity of candy enthusiasts.

The History of Dum Dums

Before we dive into the rarest flavor, let’s take a moment to appreciate the history of Dum Dums. These delightful lollipops were first introduced in 1924 by the Akron Candy Company, which later became the Spangler Candy Company. The name “Dum Dums” was chosen to appeal to children and was inspired by a popular phrase at the time, meaning “dumb person.”

Initially, Dum Dums came in just seven flavors: lemon, lime, orange, coconut-pineapple, cherry, grape, and butterscotch. Over the years, the brand expanded its flavor offerings to include unique and exciting options, such as cotton candy, root beer, and blue raspberry.

The Quest for the Rarest Flavor

With over 16 flavors currently available, determining the rarest Dum Dum flavor can be quite a challenge. However, after extensive research and analysis, it has been found that the elusive flavor is none other than the “Mystery Flavor.”

The Mystery Flavor is a result of the manufacturing process at the Spangler Candy Company. When transitioning from one flavor to another, there is a brief period where the two flavors mix, creating a unique taste. Instead of discarding this mixture, the company decided to package it as a Mystery Flavor, adding an element of surprise to the Dum Dums experience.

The Mystery Flavor has become a favorite among Dum Dums enthusiasts, as it offers a sense of adventure and unpredictability. Each Mystery Flavor lollipop is a mystery waiting to be solved, making it highly sought after by collectors and candy lovers alike.

Unveiling the Mystery

While the exact composition of the Mystery Flavor remains a closely guarded secret, there have been numerous speculations and theories about its taste. Some believe it is a combination of two or more flavors, while others think it is a completely new and unique flavor.

One popular theory suggests that the Mystery Flavor is a blend of cherry and blue raspberry. This theory is supported by the fact that the transition from cherry to blue raspberry during the manufacturing process could result in a mixture of the two flavors.

Another theory proposes that the Mystery Flavor is a combination of all the flavors used in the production line. As each flavor is introduced, a small amount remains in the machinery, leading to a blend of all the flavors present at that time.

The Rarity of the Mystery Flavor

One of the reasons the Mystery Flavor is considered the rarest Dum Dum flavor is its limited availability. The Mystery Flavor is not included in every bag of Dum Dums, making it a special find for those lucky enough to come across it.

Additionally, the Mystery Flavor is not sold individually, further adding to its rarity. To enjoy the Mystery Flavor, one must purchase a bag of assorted Dum Dums and hope to stumble upon this hidden gem.

Collecting and Trading Dum Dums

The rarity of the Mystery Flavor has sparked a vibrant community of Dum Dums collectors and traders. These enthusiasts are constantly on the lookout for the elusive Mystery Flavor and engage in trades to complete their collections.

Online platforms and forums dedicated to Dum Dums trading have emerged, allowing collectors to connect and exchange their duplicates for flavors they are missing. The Mystery Flavor holds a special place in these trading circles, often being the most sought-after and valuable addition to any collection.


1. How can I increase my chances of finding the Mystery Flavor?

Unfortunately, there is no guaranteed way to find the Mystery Flavor. It is entirely random and depends on the manufacturing process. The best approach is to enjoy Dum Dums and hope for a lucky encounter with the Mystery Flavor.

2. Are there any clues or hints to help identify the Mystery Flavor?

The packaging of the Mystery Flavor lollipops does not provide any clues or hints about its taste. The only way to uncover the Mystery Flavor is by trying it yourself.

3. Can I request the Mystery Flavor when purchasing Dum Dums?

No, the Mystery Flavor is not available for individual purchase. It can only be found in bags of assorted Dum Dums.

4. Are there any limited-edition Dum Dums flavors?

Yes, the Spangler Candy Company occasionally releases limited-edition flavors to celebrate holidays or special occasions. These flavors are highly sought after by collectors and fans of Dum Dums.

5. Can I create my own Mystery Flavor by mixing different Dum Dums?

While it may be tempting to experiment with different Dum Dums flavors, the exact composition of the Mystery Flavor remains a secret. Mixing different flavors may result in a unique taste, but it will not replicate the true Mystery Flavor.

6. Are there any other rare Dum Dums flavors?

While the Mystery Flavor holds the title of the rarest Dum Dum flavor, there are other flavors that are less commonly found. These include flavors like bubblegum, cream soda, and sour apple.


The rarest Dum Dum flavor is undoubtedly the Mystery Flavor. With its limited availability and sense of adventure, the Mystery Flavor has captured the hearts of candy enthusiasts and collectors. While the exact taste remains a mystery, the allure of the unknown makes the Mystery Flavor a highly sought-after addition to any Dum Dums collection. So, the next time you enjoy a Dum Dum, keep an eye out for the elusive Mystery Flavor and embrace the excitement of the unknown.